Showing posts with label Rand. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rand. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

On fighting a war...

Out of yesterday's Herald comes a fairly brief summary of the situation in Afghanistan and the prospects for the future of that nation and the military campaign against the Taliban.
"The weakness of state institutions, malign actions of power-brokers, widespread corruption and abuse of power by various officials, and Isaf's [International Security Assistance Force's] own errors, have given Afghans little reason to support their Government," McChrystal argued in a document leaked to Bob Woodward of the Washington Post. He said the consequence had been a "crisis of confidence among Afghans. Further, a perception that our resolve is uncertain makes Afghans reluctant to align with us against the insurgents".

That is extracted from a confidential briefing paper prepared for President Barack Obama by the senior US general in Afghanistan, Stanley McChrystal, in August 2009, eight years into the United States-led invasion of Afghanistan.
"We should honestly admit that our efforts have not led to the expected results. Huge material resources and considerable casualties did not produce a positive end result - stabilisation of military-political situation in the country. The protracted character of the military struggle and the absence of any serious success, which could lead to a breakthrough in the entire strategic situation, led to the formation in the minds of the majority of the population of the mistrust in the abilities of the regime."

"The experience of the past years clearly shows that the Afghan problem cannot be solved by military means only.

"We should decisively reject our illusions and undertake principally new steps, taking into account the lessons of the past, and the real situation in the country."

So the Americans are starting to have doubts?

Far from it, it seems. That second quote was from August 17, 1987. The writer Colonel K. Tsagalov is addressing the newly appointed Soviet Defence Minister, Dmitry Yazov.

Sunday, November 02, 2008

Libertarianism R.I.P.

An interesting little debate between Jacob Weisberg in Slate and
Richard Epstein in Forbes on the “Death of Libertarianism”, HT to my mates at ALD.

Each has their own little hobby-horses which to trot around the stage and play at jousting in the lists.

On the subject of the causes of the “current” collapse of the financial and banking systems, there is as might be expected considerable difference of opinion.

Epstein, predictably, blames government involvement and interference –
Alas, the financial rot started in the underlying home-mortgage market, with the government decision to subsidize home mortgages generally through low interest rates, and compounds the problem by offering special Fannie and Freddie guarantees at the low end of the market.
These foolish decisions prompted market actors to react just as libertarians fear: to profit privately from public foolishness. Savvy lenders looked less to the creditworthiness of their borrowers and more to unwise government guarantees that insulated them from risk. A high-risk loan of $1,000, without that guarantee, could be worth half that sum before the ink was dry. But who cares, if a government agency will pick up the slack?
Similarly, self-interested borrowers eagerly grasped at cheap-money loans, thereby driving up the price of underlying assets. But once these subsidies became too expensive to sustain, the capital markets raised the price of interest, which killed off refinancing for persons living beyond their means.

All of that is quite true, and quite logical. I am not going to argue against it.

Weisberg lays his “cause” like this –
Perhaps the most alarming moment was the failure of a giant, superleveraged hedge fund called Long-Term Capital Management, which threatened the solvency of financial institutions that served as counter-parties to its derivative contracts, much in the manner of Bear Stearns and Lehman Bros. this year. After LTCM's collapse, it became abundantly clear to anyone paying attention to this unfortunately esoteric issue that unregulated credit market derivatives posed risks to the global financial system, and that supervision and limits of some kind were advisable. This was a very scary problem and a very boring one, a hazardous combination.


Those with memories might dredge out the graphic I stole from Herald back in September; the inverted pyramid of the “money supply”. Weisberg I think could well have included that to illustrate his point.

I have to say that my views are no more valid than either of these august gentlemen. I balance that by admitting that in terms of erudition and learning they probably stand a few miles ahead of me.

I think that both these jousters are correct – in the small and very specific parts of the overall train of events that they have presented to support their respective views. That, I submit, is the danger of taking both of these gentlemen at face value and in isolation.

So, when Epstein says
” At this point, securitization, which diversified some risks, accentuated others by spreading the bad paper throughout the entire system. Now the high default rates on mortgages introduced massive uncertainty for valuing these financial instruments, which triggered government mark-to-market re-evaluations--which in turn forced a premature liquidation of assets. And presto, the failure of the Wall Street investment banks mushroomed into a larger financial crisis.”

...he is right on that thin edge of untruth. It is a matter of regulation in most markets – regulation set by the markets themselves and by the participants – that many different contract forms must be regularly, and as regularly as daily, revalued (mark to market) and the difference if negative lodged with the market. That is practice, and not something that “the government” suddenly undertook, and which he implies caused the collapse. Yes, it is likely that mark to market pressures were a major partial cause. But that was likely as a result of traders not being able to obtain the readies to lodge with the market as practice and convention required.

In my view the reality is that there was little that any government could have done to prevent the collapse of the banking and credit systems. So much of the system is based upon the fundamentals of fair dealing, of personal and commercial trust, of open and honest trading that regulation was (and still will be) an impossibility.

For that very same reason, the future control and regulation of the credit supply will continue to be at the hand of commercial practices and market convention rather than by government control.

Despite that midpoint conclusion, and to balance the number of times I quote the two protagonists, I do like Weisberg’s conclusion
The worst thing you can say about libertarians is that they are intellectually immature, frozen in the worldview many of them absorbed from reading Ayn Rand novels in high school. Like other ideologues, libertarians react to the world's failing to conform to their model by asking where the world went wrong. Their heroic view of capitalism makes it difficult for them to accept that markets can be irrational, misunderstand risk, and misallocate resources or that financial systems without vigorous government oversight and the capacity for pragmatic intervention constitute a recipe for disaster.

As I have said before – the perfect system will fail, because humans are involved in its operation.

Sunday, October 14, 2007

Utopia - and "That Hideous Strength"

The Old Whig has been reading – and this comment has been picking at my brain since he wrote on 29 September...
Now I'm reading That Hideous Strength, by C.S. Lewis, after having read Out of the Silent Planet and Perelandra - all on The Probligo's recommendation. Very enlightening stuff: pretty deep theology, delivered entertainingly. Since I'm not done with the last book of the series, I'm still not sure where there's a vision of a utopia that I'd actually want to aim for in them.


That last comment is the thorn that has been pricking my brain.

First I need to explain, and please I do not need to be told now, that when I first read the trilogy the theological references went over my head. That is until I met up with the Gaia mythology. However I know that Lewis would not have had this in his mind as he wrote. The deeper mires of Christian references I know are there and I (subconciously but perhaps intentionally) find them difficult to pin down.

Leave that aside, because it is the reference to “utopia” that is the very sharp point that I wish to pick up.
___________________________________________________________

I do not believe for a moment that Lewis had a utopian vision in mind. As I read the stories I have a far sharper picture of “dealing with existing realities” than providing an ideal future. Al may like to remember that my recommendation came as a part of a fairly barbed comment about “objectivists”. That was based upon some of the final scenes in “Hideous Strength” involving the “Objective Room” and the attempts to persuade Mark Studdock to denigrate the symbols of Christianity.

I get a far stronger message from the trilogy that, among other things, Lewis was arguing strongly of the relationships between science and religion.

On the wider front, I want to talk about utopias in general.

Yep, I am biased. There is no such thing as a practical utopia. I do not think that “Atlas” presented a practical utopia any more than “Brave New World”. I must go back and read the full “Lilliput” stories (Swift) and refresh my memory for I believe that the same message came clear and strong from him as well.

All of the stories I have read that involve the presentation of a utopia include either or both of –

The seeds of its demise – BNW is based upon the control of the society through drugs and the principle of “man is worth no more than his ability to contribute”. Add to that the element of predetermination and the future of that society does not even need the “thinking man” (in the persona of “the native”) to emphasise the flaws.

The application of a level of exclusivity; the “grand society” – such as “Atlas” and the presentation of the perfect capitalism. On a wider scale, every utopia (and distopia) has a fundamental political theme behind it that reaches into the same parts of man’s psyche as does religion.

I can not escape the feeling that every picture of “perfection” starts to crumble as soon as you put mankind into it. I prefer the reality of living as best one may, with care and with honesty, and with respect for every other person. That is not a utopia; I suspect that I would feel the same whether rich as I am in NZ or as poor as I might be in India or China or Zimbabwe. It is my environment (in what is around me and what is happening around me) that shapes my life more than sweet dreams of religious redemption or political and military power.

Monday, September 24, 2007

On public vs private health care -

Al over at The Old Whig wrote about H Clinton's public health proposals. I left this as a comment, but it is worth repeating here -

I am very much of two minds here. Or perhaps I should say two hearts.

I have had all of my treatment, surgery etc for little more than a few hundreds.

I was talking with the corporate health insurer last week and she (the rep) said that the insurers would be looking at in excess of $50,000, perhaps even closer to $100k if there had been complications. The conversation came up because my boss could not understand (and neither could she) why my mitral valve was excluded under the corporate policy. It should, apparently, have been covered. However, I have the piece of paper that says otherwise.

Using that as a guide, I have recouped probably most of the tax I have paid in total over the past 15 years.

On the other hand, how does Rand's theories cope with the refusal of a private provider to cover for some medical events. More to the point, my wife would be faced with having to help me decide between another 5 years or so of fairly restrictive life for me and a $100,000 mortgage as we move toward retirement. Suggestions?

There are whole rafts of other considerations that are being debated here in NZ - not the least of which also directly impinges from my own surgery.

For example, the number of patients on waiting lists, defects in the process of determining priority for treatment, and that is the consequence of having restricted resources available. No argument from me on the need for limiting public funding of resources but it does have some interesting sidelights.

Over the past twelve months or more there has been a very emotional and persistant campaign for the use of Herceptin as a standard treatment of breast cancer. After much pushing from the womens' rights groups Pharmac has agreed to fund a 16 week treatment course, costing some $16,000 per patient. The WRGs are still pressing for 12 months treatment - potentially costing over $100,000 per patient. Well what is wrong with that?

In the past few days, a new test for male prostate cancer has been announced. It is not yet available in NZ. It is apparently far more accurate than the existing hormone test - which gives a very high rate of false negatives.

This new test is too expensive!! Hence it will be made available only by private providers, probably at an even higher cost to the patient.

How much? Reportedly $500 or thereabouts per test...

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

Rand-om thoughts - 4

Forget about all of the stylistic complaints, the pat ending, the predictability of the plot, the fact that once past page 1000 (in the print I have) one gets the impression that Rand wanted to finish the story.

There are a couple things that need to be said about Part 3.

First is that Rand displays a considerable foresight in her depiction of the collapse of an economy. We have seen it in Russia, in Zimbabwe, it is in many respects an extension of the collapse of the German economy during the 1930’s. The detail might shift – the rise of the crime lords in Russia; the “privatization” of farmland in Zimbabwe; the fascist (but directed so similar in that respect) economy in Germany – and that may well have served as her model. But one has to admire Rand for the picture she paints. Who would have believed that the whole interstate transport system of the US was limited to one rail bridge across the Mississippi? But that is a small carp.

The second is that if Rand had wanted to shorten up the novel, she might have achieved that by leaving out the five separate expositions on Capitalism and Objectivism. They kinda form a book within the book. But again that is a small carp on the detail.

The third thing that really came home needs a step outside of Atlas Shrugged. It is not that long since I read (again, and with some considerable enjoyment) C.S. Lewis’ That Hideous Strength. The connection between the two? Lewis’ little novel, the last of the Perelandra series, features the conflict between the natural order (in the form of the planetary spirits or guides) and “the objectivists”. Lewis’ portrayal of the latter is very closely paralleled by Rand’s portrayal of the socialists/communists. Has that coloured my thoughts on Rand and her “objectivist” movement? That is possible. I will sit for a while on that and ponder further. If it is so, then it is a surprise for me as Rand’s philosophy in its broadest sense does connect with some of the outer fringes of my own beliefs.

I have left it to last, but the most interesting thing of all is the series of expositions by the major players – the bits that could perhaps have been left out of the story; the explanations of differing facets of Galt’s (Rand’s) capitalism by the members of Galt’s group, and the forty-odd pages allotted to Galt’s radio broadcast. All of these have been quoted at great length and discussed in even greater detail throughout the blogiverse by any number of devotees and disciples. I have no desire to add to that here.

What does strike me are in fact two minor offshoots.

First is the almost religious zeal of the supporters of Rand and her philosophies. Personally, I would not rate her that highly. I can find nothing in her “teachings” as they exist in Atlas Shrugged that would persuade me to follow her light, any more than Hubbard’s science fiction might convince me that Scientology is the future path of mankind. But there are obviously many – mostly American – who do rate Rand that highly.

The second is recognizing the number of times that Rand’s language and expression comes through the comments and posting of some of the more right wing of the blogiverse. I can not judge whether it is intentional, or purely because the language is “standard American political statement”. If I did not (now) know better, I would have attributed a large part of the expression to the propaganda of McCarthy, The House UnAmerican Activities Committee and similar organs of the late 1940’s and the 1950’s. As I have said, there is nothing that Rand would have taken from any of those sources (or so I am informed) which leaves the question open.

It is mirrored by the black/white nature of debate on the ‘Net. I can not blame Rand for that, it seems to be a fundamental to the American way of things – “My way or the highway” or “You are either with us or against us” if you like.

Finally, and to close this whole thing off, I am disappointed by Atlas Shrugged, given the hype and enthusiasm expressed by many. It is not any of literary significance or quality that is at issue here. It is in part style and content I admit. As I said earlier, there are parts of Rand’s thoughts which form part of my beliefs; there are areas where I could support her ideas. I can not say that Atlas Shrugged has in any persuaded me that she is more right than I. I can not say that I can agree with her philosophy in total by any stretch.

I can not explain that without writing my own philosophy – and that I am not prepared to do at present. It might happen in future.

Not now.

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Rand-om thoughts 3

Rand-om thoughts 3

I am now at the start of Part 3 of Atlas Shrugged. It has been fairly hard going. I am not going to indulge myself with a literary review. The fact that the writing is slightly turgid should not detract from the ideas being presented.

I am also going to resist presenting a critique of the Libertine political system that many like to base on the Rand ideas and her Objectivism. Sorry, did I say “Libertine”? I meant Libertarian, of course!

There is a far clearer picture formed if the book (and remember here that I have not yet read “Fountainhead”) and the idea is read in the context of the times in which it was written, and Rand’s own personal story.

Quoted from Wikipedia
Rand was twelve at the time of the Russian revolution of 1917, and her family life was disrupted by the rise of the Bolshevik party. Her father's pharmacy was confiscated by the Soviets, and the family fled to Crimea to recover financially. When Crimea fell to the Bolsheviks in 1921, Rand burned her diary, which contained vitriolic anti-Soviet writings.[5]


And from - http://www.iep.utm.edu/r/rand.htm
In 1946, Rand began work on her most ambitious novel, Atlas Shrugged. At the time she was working part-time as a screenwriter for producer Hal Wallis. In 1951 she and her husband moved to New York City, where she began to work full-time on Atlas. Published by Random House in 1957, Atlas Shrugged is her most complete expression of her literary and philosophical vision. Dramatized in the form of a mystery story about a man who stopped the motor of the world, the plot and characters embody the political and ethical themes first developed in We the Living and The Fountainhead, and integrates them into a comprehensive philosophy including metaphysics, epistemology, economics, and the psychology of love and sex.


I am not at all surprised at Rand’s intense hatred of the Communist system. That that should lead to her campaign against the Socialist tendencies of the Democrat party and more left leaning of the Republicans even is clear.

What I did not appreciate, until I started reading her books, was Rand’s insistence upon a purity of thought which would do a nun proud. There is no question that Capitalism (with capital “C”) is the Rand religion. It is the moral system, the God and the sole reason for existence. The ideas of individual and wealth are all built together in a way that makes refutation difficult. Difficult but not impossible.

I pointed out some while back (in a treatise on propaganda) that what is often more important is what is left unsaid rather than the actual content. I am not trying here to accuse Rand of writing propaganda. She is not writing (directly) for a political cause. That political offshoot has come as a result rather than as Rand’s intent.

So, when I read the first two parts of Atlas Shrugged I was struck by two central ideas that were not fully developed.

First of these is the idea of credibility. Rand’s philosophy of individual ownership centres on “Rearden Metal”, a new “metal” in the galaxy of the Periodic Table. Oh, a new alloy? Well, I can live with that despite the fact that it goes direct from mine to furnace to use – but let’s suspend credibility on that point so as to not interrupt the flow. What makes this premise even “stranger” is that this new metal is readily accessible, but only from one source as it seems. As I say, somewhat strange all round.

It also connects directly with my primary objection to the foundation of Rand’s ideas, one of the fundamentals of the CAPITALIST religion that she propounds. In reading around on the ‘net it is also an objection that has been raised more often than most. “Rearden Metal” was discovered in part because the resource that provides steel was being misused, abused and was becoming scarce. It is the Rand fundamental that in these circumstances capitalism produces new alternative and replacement products. Leave out all of the other objections – it is a matter of faith that “Rearden Metal” exists and was not previously “discovered”. I am not going to take the iron ore / coal arguments any further either simply because it is apparent that others with far better brain and argument have already been there.

I want to tackle Rand on a related but different front.

The first part of Atlas Shrugged tells of the development of Colorado as a manufacturing powerhouse, and the importance of Taggart Intercontinental in fostering that development. Taggart’s contribution was the construction of (let us say) 450 miles of railway from point A outside Colorado to point B inside Colorado primarily to service the output from one copper mine and a shale oil field. OK, let’s not go there either because it will not serve any purpose. It is a matter of faith.

The “mistake” that Rand has made is very simple. A railway requires land. It stretches credulity just a little too far that one can draw a line on a map (as is described in the story) and then go out and start laying track along that line. Surely there would be geographical features (other than the one canyon requiring a bridge) that would need to be overcome. Oh there is mention of grand sweeping curves that trains can negotiate at a speed of 100 mph compared with the existing maximum of 60mph but that mention is more to promote the advances made through the discovery of “Rearden Metal” than any improvement in rail technology.

There is one feature that is never mentioned. Who owned the land before the rail went over it? How was the right to use that land obtained? Or do Taggart’s have some strange technology that creates land just where they want to put their railway?

One of the features of Rand’s writings, one which for the moment defeats me completely because it is such a fundamental flaw in the foundations of her ideas and writing, is that of existing ownerships and rights. The fact of private and individual ownership is the whole basis of her Capitalism. There is no limitation upon the accumulation of wealth. It is laissez faire in its absolute and purest sense.

The picture that Rand has painted over with her leading characters is one of total, global poverty. Exclude her occasional glimpses at the Soviet Republic of Europe, or Soviet Republic of South America. I am concentrating only on the US as she portrays it through the story. There is no recognition of any ownership by anyone other than the main characters, including the State, at the beginning of the story. There is description of the appropriation of private property, at some length, through the first two parts. But, it seems, this (mis)appropriation affects only the major players. No one else has anything that is capable of or worth State confiscation. There is no ownership of land, there is no ownership of income from private business, there are only the proles who comprise the disadvantaged masses created by the Socialists. The occasional mention of – as an example – a taxi driver does not make it clear whether he is working for his own account, for someone else’s business, or as a “State employee”. There is no interaction between the taxi hirer and the driver other than the mention of a $100 tip (I just read that bit...  ) or the difficulty of getting anywhere in all of the traffic.

This leads on to the whole discussion – so popular over the last little while in the blogiverse – of private domain. As sure as eggs if I owned a farm somewheres along that arbitrary line on the map I would have something to say about the railway that passes through the middle of the house. Even if all the trains are on time.

But, as I said before, let’s not spoil a good story by getting too practical about it.

Finally, and while I talk of taxis, that is one of the better laughs in the story thus far.

Following a long discussion, some 18 pages, of privations, problems and causes of the oil and fuel shortage to set the scene for the shale oil business in Colorado one of the main characters (Dagny as I recall) walks out of the building and immediately hails a taxi that then drives off into the deserted streets... But hey, let’s not have the occasional wardrobe slip spoil a good yarn.

Let me be very clear. My politic has no room for communism despite my very brief contacts with the outside of the movement in my (somewhat naive) teen years. I was raised in a nation that has a proud history of socialism founded upon the responsibility of the State for the individual. Much of that State “cradle to grave” mentality has been removed during my lifetime. That was not unexpected. It is a series of events that I had expected in my youth; not in terms of the specific detail but rather in terms of the process becoming increasingly unsupportable. It might interest those who support Rand to know that Prime Minister Savage, leader of the first Labour Government, was a Socialist and devout Christian. He described the new “WelfareState” as “Christianity in Action”. For Rand herself – being an atheist – such a description would be as much an anathema as communism.

Can I put it this way. The success of a good story is a matter of credibility. One could look to Brave New World or 1984 as examples in the same category where that credibility has been achieved. Yes, both of those examples have “holes” of their own but they are not central to the theme. Regrettably, Rand’s attempt at the same has failed somewhat. The defects in her foundation do affect (my) appreciation of her theme.

I have not yet reached the end of Atlas Shrugged. I am pressing onward toward the end, and at the same time making the effort to understand the principles that Rand espouses. I am sure that I will have considerably less success in that understanding than the very many scholars who have analysed her writing in fine detail. I am doing my utmost to keep an open mind to the end.

Friday, August 03, 2007

Rand-om thoughts 2

It is difficult to know, when I write something like this, whether it is the idea that I am arguing against or the presentation and semantics of that idea.

The chapter headed “What is Capitalism?” is an interesting read on several levels. It sets the whole basis for the remainder of the discussion (as one might expect) and for that reason alone the fact that Rand spends a good part of the chapter in a critique of a mid-1960’s Encyclopedia Brittanica entry on “Capitalism” is quite unique.

It is not until the 8th page of the chapter that Rand gets to her own “definition” of Capitalism in any formal sense.
Capitalism is a social system based upon the recognition of individual rights, including property rights, in which all property is privately owned.


Like the “I support law and order” referendum this definition is near impossible to refute. One does get into the semantic definition of “rights” and “property”. Having been through this mill several times with different people, one has to accept arguing the definitions of these two basics creates far less light than smoke especially with the supporters of Rand and to a lesser extent the fundamentalist capitalists.

So if you want to debate the definition of “rights” as an issue go seek out the likes of TF Stern who makes a very good fist of “God-given” right, or the Libertarians (see Al of The Old Whig for contacts). I am happy to accept that Rand has in mind the widest meaning of the term. I have some reservations about the consequences of applying that level of “rights” in the general society. Those reservations have some impact upon how I feel about Rand’s writing and I can only request that the reader respect that to be the case. Is that valid? Given that Rand adopts a similar approach – in that I have read thus far - I can say with some certainty that the “unsupported” statement of opinion is the norm rather than the exception.

I can make the same statement about the definition of “property”. Rand has given her definition of Capitalism framed in the widest possible application of the term “property”. It is an approach which seems to give her one or two difficulties later in the book. I am still in the process of reading, digesting and re-reading those later chapters so judgement is at this time still reserved.

The third pillar that Rand puts beneath her definition is that of “objectivity”. No, don’t go look up the definition in the dictionary because Rand means something very specifically different. Try Wikipedia for initial leads if the desire to know more really grabs ya.
Capitalism is the only system based upon an objective theory of values.


Rand makes the distinction between three “systems” of valuation – objective, intrinsic and subjectivist. To give an instance of her language, this is the sentence following the definition immediately above –
The intrinsic theory and the subjectivist theory (or a mixture of both) are the necessary base of every dictatorship, tyranny, or variant of the absolute state.


Now I had to read extremely carefully through these ideas as Rand uses terms such as “right”, “value” and “action” in an almost seamless series of interchangeabilities. The connection between the useages comes with the word “good” (used as a noun) which when I learned economics had a very specific meaning. With Rand we find the term being used in statements such as the following –
If a man believes that the good [note that the use here appears to be as a noun] is intrinsic [which Rand has just defined as a system of values] in certain actions, he will not hesitate to force others to perform them. If he believes that the human benefit or injury caused by such actions is of no significance, he will regard a sea of blood as of no significance...


What has to be clear in one’s mind is that Rand is speaking of “the common good”, or “the public interest”. Given that she equates these two ideas with the extremes of collectivism and the fundamental of Socialist states such as Russia it becomes clear that the “economic” meaning I learned is not what she intended. But that does not stop the interchanging of the “good” as an “object” starting at the level of intellectual property and the idea of ”individual surplus” -
...the work, the energy, the creative over-abundance of those men whose ability produces more than their personal consumption requires, those who are intellectually and financially able to seek the new, to improve on the known, to move forward.

So, where does that leave me?

Like so many others, Rand trumpets the rail system of the US as a key example of the private sector operating in the “common good”. It is a good example. It has a very unique history; one which deserves detailed reading particularly for the 50 years from 1890 to 1940. There were a number of private railways in NZ over the years; some more extensive than others. In Auckland we had as an example the West Coast Tramway, a light rail that ran around the coast via a number of tunnels and small timber trestles. It lasted for as long as the kauri timber was economic to extract. There was the Westfield Meat Company line, used to connect their abbatoir with the meat packing plant and public railhead. Further south, Carter Timber had an extensive narrow guage system in the Mamaku Ranges using US Shay and Climax locomotives. Fascinating to watch; which I can say I was fortunate enough to do on two occasions. That is long since gone after the timber ran out. The point is that none of these (or the other examples that I could dredge out) were for public use, nor lasted past their private use.

It interests me that I have never read of the capitalist system devoting resources voluntarily to the disposal of production waste, or the provision of sewage disposal systems for their workers. There is nothing in the definitions that I have seen, nor in the very many debates upon capitalism vs anything and everything else that even acknowledges the “cost” (and it is a direct monetary cost in the long term) of environmental impact and disposal of waste.

In England, the ability to move from one place to another has always been by means of “The King’s High Way”. There is much learned legal debate on the definition of both the status of the land required and the individual right of passage. The economic consequence of that legal status is, however, that the need for private roading systems is very limited. In NZ, private roading has generally been developed by a land owner to facilitate the extraction of product or material from source to public transportation system. What there has never been, and the reasons for this might be an interesting debate, is the duplication of public roading for competitive advantage. Quite the reverse in fact. The capitalist system has always looked to higher authorities to provide public transportation systems. To be clear here, I am not referring to buses or metro. By “public transportation systems” I mean the roads, the canals, and in most countries rail as well, one could include airports and seaports; all of the infrastructure required.

Yet even in the US we very rarely see competitive duplication of these reources. The principle reason is that duplication is wasteful of other resources (such as land). Yes, there are “privately owned” toll roads in the US, in Britain, and even mooted in NZ. In the instances of which I am aware none of those roads compete with “equivalent product” but rely upon government capital contribution and the “substitution product” for the users’ time.

One can follow a similar line of reasoning with an airport – with each airline wanting access to New York having to fund and provide its own airport facility. Would not happen? It was the norm with shipping until recently. Remember the hooha when the last of the US owned “ports” in New York was sold to foreign capital? That was just within the past twelve months. How long did duplicated track systems formed by competing railroad companies exist within the US? That is one of the reasons why I earlier specified the 50 year period to 1940 as being of specific interest.

As much as Rand might not like the fact, it remains that “public good” is an essential part of a capitalist economic system. It is so to prevent the unnecessary wasteage of resources. Those resources may be land, or perhaps copper wire for a telephone local loop, or even water as the Aussies are finding out with the five year drought in the Murray Basin. That latter is an interesting example that I shall return to in a later post. Related to the Murray Basin example might be the Newfoundland cod fishery. How many in the US and Canada have tasted cod and chips in the past twenty years?

How is about energy generation and distribution? Ask a New Yorker about power cuts. Ask a Californian about the cost of "imported" power. There are elements of this appearing in NZ where the public ownership (quite a different thing from "public good") has been replaced by private ownership based on the Californian model. Objective consideration of the problems faced both in the US and in NZ will show that there is no incentive built into the capitalist models for the security of supply. The supply is always to the highest bidder so a shortage of power whether short or long term is of little to no consequence because the return on investment is guaranteed. When pricing of supply exceeds the ability of the "poor end" of the market to pay the supply stops.


What is also interesting to note is that so many of the broad categories of “public good” have high “strategic” values – transportation systems (all of them), energy generation and distribution, and resource protection.

It is that strategic value that thinkers such as Rand often seem to lose sight of...

Thursday, July 26, 2007

Rand-om Thoughts 1

It is strange, in a way, to start reading a "new" author such as Ayn Rand particularly when the writing is preceded by the kind of reputation that Rand has.

As a matter of accident as much as anything else, the first reading was Capitalism – The Unknown Ideal; a collection of essays rather than a consolidated study. Included in the book are "guest" essays from Nathaniel Brandon, Alan Greenspan, and Robert Hessen. To further compound the confusion, I did not read the essays front to back, but began with the first essay What is Capitalism then – because of Rand’s own references – to the Appendices comprising The Nature of Government and Man’s Rights.

At least I can give Rand top marks for honesty – the very first two sentences in her Introduction read –
This book is not a treatise on economics. It is a collection of essays on the moral aspects of capitalism.

To debate the morality of a topic is – as I have already found out – extremely difficult. It does however explain the first of the misgivings that I have about these of Rand’s writings. There is nothing that one can say is "wrong" in the same way as one can not vote "No" in a Statutory Referendum that asks the question "I support the principles of Law and Order". It also leads to the first of my criticisms, as far as they go –

It is a pity perhaps that Rand died before the internet and particularly the blogiverse were developed. The prospect of serious debate between Rand, (to choose contemporaries of hers) Friedman, Samuelson and Galbraith in a public forum would be just too juicy to let pass. Sadly, it is not to be. For me to critique Rand’s economics is a cheek indeed but one which is not put aside too easily.

But the connect between Rand and internet has another aspect; one which bothers me somewhat.

Her essays read very much like the kind of items that I have penned as the probligo on both my own site and as comment on others. Not so much in content or message as in form. You know, the kind of thing that TAOTB, Dave Justus and the rest get their knickers knotted about like "Where is the supporting data?"... But then, if you are talking morality there is no supporting data, huh!!

So, the initial reaction based upon what I have read thus far is of a blancmange – a junket – of dubious consistency and made from low fat milk. Put another way, the content of the three essays read so far has been very difficult to disagree with. The principles expounded by Rand are so general and of fundamental basis that any disagreement is nonsensical. However, that is like the Statutory Referendum I referred to earlier. The statement is formed in such a way that any other answer is wrong. If you accept the fundamental premise then Rand’s argument is indisputable. In order to disagree with Rand you have to disagree with the base premise. It is not that black and white I believe...

I shall ponder and shall write further, as time permits...